Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Insurance Agent — Last updated October 31, 2026
Cigna critical illness insurance pays a lump sum for many conditions, including cancer, heart attack and stroke; cancer insurance pays only for cancer. Pick critical illness for broad protection at work. Consider a cancer-only plan if cancer is your main worry or you want benefits tied to treatment.
Both products are supplemental. Neither one pays your doctor, and neither counts as major medical coverage. They pay cash to you. The difference is what triggers the cash and how much you get for each event. For the general version of this question, see cancer insurance vs critical illness.
With Cigna, the comparison has a twist. Cigna group critical illness is written by Cigna Health and Life Insurance Company through employers. The individual Cigna-branded cancer plans, Lump Sum Cancer and Cancer Treatment insurance, are now insured by Loyal American Life, an HCSC company, after HCSC bought Cigna’s supplemental business in a deal that closed March 19, 2025.
✔ Group vs individual
✔ Lump sum vs treatment-based