Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Highest Rated Critical Illness Insurance: Carriers Highly Rated by AM Best

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Insurance Agent — Last updated October 31, 2026

Several major critical illness insurers hold AM Best financial strength ratings of A++ or A+ (Superior), including Guardian, MetLife, Aflac, Mutual of Omaha, Combined Insurance (Chubb) and The Hartford. A high rating speaks to the insurer’s ability to pay claims. It does not tell you which policy pays best for your diagnosis.

Critical illness insurance pays a lump sum when you are diagnosed with a covered condition. You might wait years or decades before you file a claim, so the insurer’s financial strength matters. AM Best is the rating agency that focuses on insurance companies, and its Financial Strength Rating (FSR) is the most common way to compare them.

Below are carriers that sell critical illness coverage and are highly rated by AM Best, with the exact rating, the insurer entity rated and the date of the rating action we verified. Ratings change, so confirm the current rating before you buy. We do not rank one carrier as “best”; the right plan depends on its terms, price and your needs.

✔ Verified AM Best ratings
✔ A++ and A+ = Superior
✔ Ratings are not plan quality

Key Takeaways

✔

Guardian Life Insurance Company of America holds AM Best’s top rating, A++ (Superior), affirmed September 2025.

✔

MetLife, Aflac, Mutual of Omaha, Combined Insurance Company of America (Chubb) and Hartford Life and Accident hold A+ (Superior).

✔

Unum’s core U.S. subsidiaries, including Colonial Life, and Cigna Health and Life Insurance Company hold A (Excellent).

✔

A financial strength rating measures ability to pay claims, not benefit design or customer service.

✔

Always compare covered conditions, partial benefits, waiting periods and price alongside the rating.

Compare Highly Rated Carriers

AM Best Ratings for Major Critical Illness Carriers

Carrier Rated insurer entity AM Best FSR Rating action verified
Guardian Guardian Life Insurance Company of America A++ (Superior) Affirmed Sept. 2025
MetLife Metropolitan Life Insurance Company A+ (Superior) Affirmed Apr. 2026
Aflac American Family Life Assurance Company of Columbus and Aflac life/health subsidiaries A+ (Superior) Affirmed Sept. 2025
Mutual of Omaha Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company and subsidiaries incl. United of Omaha A+ (Superior) Affirmed Apr. 2026
Chubb (Combined) Combined Insurance Company of America A+ (Superior) Affirmed; reported Jan. 2026
The Hartford Hartford Life and Accident Insurance Company A+ (Superior) Affirmed Jul. 2026
Unum / Colonial Life Unum Life Insurance Company of America, Colonial Life & Accident and other core U.S. subsidiaries A (Excellent) Affirmed Sept. 2025
Cigna Cigna Health and Life Insurance Company A (Excellent) Affirmed Mar. 2026

Outlook: The rating releases we reviewed listed a stable outlook for each of these ratings.

Sources: AM Best rating action press releases published via Business Wire and other outlets. Ratings can be upgraded, downgraded or placed under review at any time.

What an AM Best Rating Means

AM Best assigns Financial Strength Ratings to insurers based on balance sheet strength, operating performance, business profile and enterprise risk management. The top categories are:

AM Best FSR AM Best descriptor What it tells you
A++ and A+ Superior Superior ability to meet ongoing insurance obligations
A and A- Excellent Excellent ability to meet ongoing insurance obligations
B++ and B+ Good Good ability to meet ongoing insurance obligations

What a rating does not measure

✕

Whether a specific policy pays well for your condition

✕

How fast or fairly claims are handled

✕

Price or value of the premium

✕

Customer service quality

✕

Whether a product is sold in your state

Talk It Through With a Licensed Insurance Agent

Free help comparing hospital indemnity plans in your state. No obligation.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

Carrier Snapshots

Guardian: A++ (Superior)

✔

Guardian Life Insurance Company of America and core subsidiaries affirmed at A++ in September 2025

✔

Common in employer voluntary benefit packages

MetLife: A+ (Superior)

✔

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company affirmed at A+ in April 2026

✔

Large workplace benefits provider

Aflac: A+ (Superior)

✔

American Family Life Assurance Company of Columbus affirmed at A+ in September 2025

✔

Sells individual critical illness policies, with online quote and apply for individuals

Mutual of Omaha: A+ (Superior)

✔

Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company and subsidiaries affirmed at A+ in April 2026

✔

Individual brochure lists $10,000 to $100,000 benefit amounts

Chubb, The Hartford, Unum and Cigna

✔

Combined Insurance Company of America (Chubb): A+; see Chubb critical illness insurance

✔

Hartford Life and Accident: A+; see The Hartford critical illness insurance

✔

Unum core subsidiaries incl. Colonial Life: A; see Unum critical illness insurance

✔

Cigna Health and Life: A; see Cigna critical illness insurance

Get Quotes From Highly Rated Insurers

Rating vs. Policy: Why Both Matter

Two highly rated insurers can sell very different policies. Compare published examples:

Feature Mutual of Omaha individual brochure Aflac lump-sum policy form (GA)
Benefit amounts $10,000 to $100,000 Set in policy schedule
Heart attack, stroke, internal cancer 100% 100% initial diagnosis
Partial benefits 25% first-ever coronary artery disease or angioplasty 25% bypass, 25% noninvasive cancer
Second event One-time benefit per policy design 50% subsequent event benefit
Extra feature Return of premium on death Optional hospitalization and recovery riders

A high rating tells you the insurer should be there to pay. The policy terms tell you what it will pay.

How to Compare Highly Rated Plans

Comparison steps

1

Confirm the rating: Check the current AM Best rating for the exact insurer entity on your policy.

2

Check the condition list: Make sure it covers the conditions you worry about most.

3

Check partial benefits: See what pays 25% or 50% instead of 100%.

4

Check limits: Note waiting periods and the pre-existing condition look-back.

5

Compare price: Get quotes at your age and benefit amount.

6

Check availability: Confirm the plan is sold in your state or by your employer.

Talk It Through With a Licensed Insurance Agent

Free help comparing hospital indemnity plans in your state. No obligation.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

Compare Plans With a Licensed Insurance Agent

Pros and Cons of Choosing by Rating

Pros

✔ Signals strong ability to pay future claims.

✔ Easy, independent way to screen insurers.

✔ Highly rated carriers often have long claims histories.

Cons

! Does not measure benefit design or price.

! Ratings apply to a specific legal entity, not always the brand.

! Ratings can change after you buy.

Also weigh how critical illness fits with other coverage. See critical illness vs. hospital indemnity and cancer insurance vs. critical illness.

Notes on Cigna and Brand Names

Brand names and the insurer on your policy are not always the same. Aflac policies are issued by American Family Life Assurance Company of Columbus. Chubb accident and health coverage in the U.S. is often issued by Combined Insurance Company of America. Cigna sold its Medicare Advantage, Cigna Supplemental Benefits, Part D and CareAllies businesses to HCSC in a deal that closed March 19, 2025, so individual supplemental policies once sold under the Cigna name may now sit with a different insurer. Check the company name printed on the policy and look up that entity’s rating.

The Bottom Line

The highest rated critical illness insurers by AM Best include Guardian at A++ and MetLife, Aflac, Mutual of Omaha, Combined Insurance (Chubb) and The Hartford at A+. Use the rating to screen insurers, then choose a plan by its covered conditions, partial benefits, limits and price.

Talk to a Licensed Insurance Agent

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Which critical illness insurance company has the highest AM Best rating?

Among the major carriers we checked, Guardian Life Insurance Company of America holds A++ (Superior), AM Best’s highest rating, affirmed in September 2025.

➤ What AM Best rating does Aflac have?

American Family Life Assurance Company of Columbus and Aflac’s life and health subsidiaries hold an A+ (Superior) Financial Strength Rating, affirmed in September 2025.

➤ What is MetLife’s AM Best rating?

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company holds an A+ (Superior) Financial Strength Rating, affirmed by AM Best in April 2026.

➤ What is Mutual of Omaha’s AM Best rating?

Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company and its subsidiaries, including United of Omaha, hold an A+ (Superior) rating, affirmed in April 2026.

➤ Is an A rating from AM Best good?

Yes. A and A- are in the Excellent category. A++ and A+ are in the Superior category, the highest tier.

➤ Does a high rating mean the policy is the best?

No. The rating measures financial strength. Benefits, definitions, limits and price vary by policy, so compare those too.

➤ What rating do Unum and Colonial Life have?

Unum’s core U.S. subsidiaries, including Unum Life Insurance Company of America and Colonial Life and Accident Insurance Company, hold an A (Excellent) rating, affirmed in September 2025.

➤ How do I check an insurer’s current AM Best rating?

Look up the exact insurer named on your policy on AM Best’s website or in the insurer’s latest rating press release. Ratings can change at any time.

Have Questions?

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company