Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Colonial Life Critical Illness Insurance Cost: Real Rates by Age and Amount

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Insurance Agent — Last updated October 31, 2026

Colonial Life critical illness insurance cost ranges from about $5 every two weeks for a young worker with $10,000 of coverage to well over $100 a month for an older tobacco user who adds cancer. Age, face amount, tobacco use and the cancer option drive most of the price.

Colonial Life does not publish one national price list. Each employer group gets its own rates, and they depend on the plan design and state. The good news is that many employers post their Colonial Life rate sheets online. We pulled the numbers below from two of them so you can see real prices, not guesses.

Use this page to estimate your cost and to see which choices raise or lower it. For what the plan pays, see Colonial Life critical illness insurance coverage. For the product basics, start with Colonial Life critical illness insurance.

✔ Real employer rate sheets
✔ Age and tobacco pricing
✔ Cancer option cost

Key Takeaways

✔

A 2026 Massachusetts group plan charged $4.73 to $63.02 every two weeks for employee-only, non-tobacco coverage, depending on age and face amount.

✔

In one individual plan, tobacco users paid roughly 23% to 56% more than non-tobacco users for the same $25,000 benefit.

✔

Adding cancer coverage to that plan raised the non-tobacco monthly premium by $4.25 to $54.75, depending on age.

✔

Some plans lock your rate to your age when you enroll, so buying younger can lower your lifetime cost.

✔

Rates vary by employer, state and plan design. Use these as real examples, not quotes.

Get a Free Critical Illness Price Check

Real Rates: 2026 Group Plan (Bi-Weekly)

These are the employee-only, non-tobacco rates from the City of Peabody, Massachusetts, 2026 Colonial Life group critical illness plan. The plan covers cancer, heart attack, stroke, organ failure, renal failure and coma. It is paid every two weeks.

Age band $10,000 $20,000 $30,000
20-29 $4.73 $6.39 $8.05
30-39 $6.35 $9.62 $12.90
40-49 $9.85 $16.64 $23.42
50-59 $15.49 $27.90 $40.32
60-74 $23.05 $43.04 $63.02

To turn a bi-weekly rate into a yearly cost, multiply by 26. A 45-year-old with $20,000 of coverage would pay $16.64 x 26 = $432.64 a year, or about $36 a month.

Note: The plan sheet says cost and coverage stay the same after you leave your job and that the rate is based on your age at enrollment. Other plans may use age bands that rise as you get older.

Real Rates: Individual Plan With and Without Cancer (Monthly)

This table comes from a Colonial Life Specified Critical Illness 1.0 HSA-compliant plan summary posted by an employer in 2024. It shows monthly rates for employee-only coverage with a $25,000 face amount, subsequent diagnosis and a health screening benefit.

Issue age Non-tobacco Tobacco Non-tobacco + cancer Tobacco + cancer
17-24 $10.65 $13.15 $14.90 $19.15
25-29 $12.65 $16.65 $20.15 $27.90
30-34 $15.15 $21.90 $25.90 $38.90
35-39 $22.40 $32.15 $34.65 $53.15
40-44 $26.65 $41.65 $41.90 $66.65
45-49 $35.15 $54.15 $55.40 $86.15
50-54 $46.65 $70.40 $77.90 $118.90
55-59 $58.40 $90.65 $96.65 $152.15
60-64 $74.40 $111.65 $129.15 $196.15

Talk It Through With a Licensed Insurance Agent

Free help comparing hospital indemnity plans in your state. No obligation.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

Compare Prices From Several Insurers

What Drives Your Colonial Life Premium

THE SIX PRICE LEVERS

1

Age: The biggest factor. In the group table, the $20,000 rate rises from $6.39 in your 20s to $43.04 at 60-74.

2

Face amount: More coverage costs more, but not in a straight line. Going from $10,000 to $30,000 at ages 20-29 adds only $3.32 every two weeks.

3

Tobacco use: At ages 40-44, the tobacco rate is $41.65 a month vs. $26.65 for non-tobacco in the individual plan.

4

Cancer option: At ages 40-44, adding cancer moves the non-tobacco rate from $26.65 to $41.90.

5

Who you cover: Spouse and family tiers cost more. One plan covers a spouse at 50% and children at 25% of your amount.

6

Plan extras: Subsequent diagnosis and health screening benefits are built into some rates and not others.

Your employer’s group size and plan design also matter. Two people of the same age can see different Colonial Life prices at different companies.

What You Get Back for the Premium

Cost only means something next to the payout. A covered heart attack or stroke usually pays 100% of the face amount. Bypass surgery pays 25%.

Example (group plan, age 40-49) Yearly premium Payout for a 100% condition Years of premium one claim covers
$10,000 coverage $256.10 $10,000 About 39
$20,000 coverage $432.64 $20,000 About 46
$30,000 coverage $608.92 $30,000 About 49

The math above uses the Peabody bi-weekly rates times 26. Higher face amounts give you more benefit per premium dollar in this plan.

Screening offset: The same plan pays $100 a year when you complete a covered screening such as a mammogram, colonoscopy, PSA or cholesterol test. For a worker in their 20s with $10,000 of coverage, that $100 covers most of the $122.98 yearly premium.

Colonial Life Critical Illness Cost vs. Hospital Indemnity Cost

Hospital indemnity is priced differently because it pays per hospital stay, not per diagnosis. For example, a 2026 Cigna employer hospital plan at Dartmouth charged $11.23 a month for employee-only low-plan coverage and $22.27 for the high plan. See more on our hospital indemnity insurance cost page.

Critical illness cost

✔ Rises sharply with age

✔ Tobacco and cancer options add a lot

✔ Pays a large sum for a few serious conditions

Hospital indemnity cost

! Often flatter by age in group plans

! Pays for any covered hospital stay

! Smaller amounts per stay or per day

Many families buy both. Read critical illness insurance vs. hospital indemnity to see how they split the job.

Price Both Plans in One Call

Ways to Lower Your Cost

MISTAKES THAT RAISE YOUR COST

✕

Waiting until an older age band to enroll

✕

Buying more face amount than your deductible gap needs

✕

Adding cancer twice if you already have a separate cancer policy

✕

Skipping the yearly screening benefit you already paid for

✕

Dropping coverage at job change when it is portable

Start with your health plan’s out-of-pocket maximum. One simple approach is to size the face amount to cover that number plus a few months of bills. Then decide on cancer. If you already own a cancer policy, you may not need cancer inside your critical illness plan too.

Talk It Through With a Licensed Insurance Agent

Free help comparing hospital indemnity plans in your state. No obligation.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

Is the Cost Worth It?

It depends on your savings and your health plan. If a $10,000 surprise bill would force you onto a credit card, a small premium can be worth it. If you have a large emergency fund, you may skip it. Our guide is critical illness insurance worth it walks through the decision, and our critical illness insurance guide explains the product in plain terms.

When you are ready to compare prices, see Colonial Life critical illness insurance quotes for how to get them.

Talk to a Licensed Insurance Agent

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

Real Colonial Life rate sheets show critical illness coverage can cost under $5 every two weeks for a young worker and more than $150 a month for an older tobacco user with cancer coverage. Age, tobacco and the cancer option move the price most. Compare your employer’s rate sheet to the payout you would get, and size the face amount to your real out-of-pocket risk.

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ How much does Colonial Life critical illness insurance cost?

It depends on age, face amount, tobacco use and plan. One 2026 group plan charged $4.73 to $63.02 every two weeks for employee-only, non-tobacco coverage.

➤ Does Colonial Life charge more for tobacco users?

Yes. In one individual plan, a 40-44 year old paid $41.65 a month as a tobacco user vs. $26.65 as a non-tobacco user for $25,000 of coverage.

➤ How much does adding cancer cost?

In one Colonial Life plan, cancer added $4.25 to $54.75 a month for non-tobacco users and $6.00 to $84.50 for tobacco users, for a $25,000 face amount.

➤ Do Colonial Life rates go up with age?

Some plans price on your age at enrollment and keep that rate. Others use age bands. Check your plan’s rate sheet.

➤ Is Colonial Life critical illness insurance paid by payroll deduction?

Usually yes when you enroll at work. Policyholders can also view premiums and make payments in Colonial Life’s online account.

➤ Is it cheaper than hospital indemnity?

Not always. A young worker may pay less for critical illness, while an older worker may pay more. One 2026 Cigna hospital plan cost $11.23 to $22.27 a month for employee-only coverage.

➤ Can the health screening benefit offset my premium?

Yes, in plans that include it. One plan pays $100 a year for a covered screening, which can cover most of a young worker’s yearly premium.

➤ Can I keep the same rate if I leave my job?

Many plans are portable. One 2026 group plan says cost and coverage stay the same after you leave.

Have Questions?

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company